Menu of Marty's Steakhouse in Reedsburg, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Marty's Steakhouse, nestled at 200 Viking Dr in Reedsburg, WI, offers a quintessential American steakhouse experience with a touch of nostalgic charm. This establishment stands out not only for its hearty steaks but also for a thoughtfully crafted menu that caters to both classic steak lovers and families seeking comfort fare.

The highlight of Marty's Steakhouse menu rests firmly on its steak offerings. The 8oz Rib Eye Steak Sandwich, broiled to perfection and served on toast, showcases their dedication to quality cuts and robust flavor. Complementing the steaks are mouthwatering alternatives like the Philly Wrap and the stacked Prime Rib Philly Sandwich, both rich with tender prime rib, sautéed peppers, onions, mushrooms, and melted Swiss cheese—capturing the essence of a hearty, satisfying meal.

For younger guests or those young at heart, Marty's excels in providing familiar favorites with a wholesome twist. The Mini Corn Dogs served alongside French fries are a fun, crispy starter, while options like the Kiddiburger crafted from fresh ground beef ensure children enjoy a proper meal. Seafood enthusiasts are well served too; the Popcorn Shrimp and Breaded Chicken Strips deliver a satisfying crunch and flavor that have earned positive nods from patrons.

The Luncheon Specials, particularly the Soup and Salad Bar, afford a lighter yet fresh accompaniment to any meal. While the salad bar has been noted as average by some customers, its inclusion provides a balanced option for those who prefer greens alongside their steakhouse delights.

What sets Marty's apart is not just the menu but the warmth of its service and atmosphere. Patrons like Kimberly Reynolds praise servers such as Gisselle for attentive care, enhancing the overall dining experience. The comforting, old-fashioned ambiance, as described by guests, invites families seeking a relaxed meal, with ample parking and easy access adding to convenience despite a somewhat hidden entrance.

Special occasions at Marty's Steakhouse feel intimate and memorable, as CaSandra Helgerson's recount of her parents’ 56th wedding anniversary beautifully illustrates. The kitchen's flexibility—cutting steaks to share and offering perfect appetizers like clam strips and tempura shrimp—alongside polite service creates a heartfelt experience in a setting where even watching nearby wildlife adds to the evening’s charm.

In summary, Marty's Steakhouse presents a menu that blends classic steakhouse staples with family-friendly dishes, supported by genuine hospitality. The quality of the prime rib, the variety in the menu, and attentive service combine into an appealing destination for those craving hearty, well-prepared American fare in Reedsburg.